fbpx Click here to design your own engagement ring

Having difficulty choosing between two equally captivating center stones? You are not alone! Our diamond and gemstone engagement rings make it difficult for any bride to choose just one—especially when her heart yearns for both. Luckily, we are here to help you along the way!

This post offers information on both of these center stones, their characteristics, and what makes them so exceptional. We even listed two of our most-requested choices from our collection to help narrow your search. Finally, we’ll recommend which center stone pairs best with which metal and setting. Let’s get started!

Diamond Engagement Rings

When you think of diamond engagement rings, do you think of a classic, traditional engagement ring? Most people do, and it’s because they are always beautiful and have a timeless feel that most brides dream about. Diamond engagement rings in any shape or style, never go out of style and they look great on everyone. Each engagement ring in the Sylvie Jewelry is carefully checked and has to go through a 150 point inspection process, so you can count on getting only the highest quality engagement ring. All of diamond engagement rings are designed with love in mind, which means that your proposal will be extra special.

Gemstone Engagement Rings

Gemstone engagement rings bring both a unique element and a pop of color to an otherwise classic engagement ring. They can feature birthstones, gem side stones, or even use two or more Emeralds, rubies, sapphires, and morganite gemstone engagement rings are a perfect mix of glamorous and out of the box. For the non traditional bride who doesn’t want a classic diamond, a blue sapphire or morganite center is more budget friendly and adds that unique element she’s been looking for. All of our engagement rings can be customized to include gemstone centers or even side stones to accompany the center diamond.


lazy placeholder

(Style shown: S1093)

A fan favorite, this timeless and classic solitaire engagement ring features a dazzling 1 carat round brilliant diamond in a prong setting and placed upon a shank accented with a total weight of 0.21 carats of cascading pave diamonds.

lazy placeholder

(Style shown: S1993)

This sparkling round halo engagement ring features a 1 carat oval cut peridot center stone that sits within our signature halo. The contrast between the light green and the rose gold makes for a unique and out of the box engagement ring that your adventurous bride would love.

peridot halo engagement ring sylvie S1993 2

(Style shown: S1859) 

This dazzling ring features a pink sapphire center surrounded by a gorgeous halo with a rose gold stackable band. It is modern, out of the box, and a glamorous mix of unique and romantic. This is a great example of your customization options with a rose gold stackable band, a pink sapphire center, and a white gold halo.

rose gold pink sapphire engagement ring sylvie S1859


Ever shopped for a pair of sunglasses? It’s so easy to select a sleek pair of shades, and just as easy to reject them once you try them on. Choosing between a diamond engagement ring and a gemstone one can be a similar struggle.

So which will it be, diamond or gemstone?

For more information on finding the perfect diamond engagement ring, subscribe to our newsletter, or find a retailer near you.

Looking for fashion trends, advice, and more? Follow us on FacebookTwitterPinterest and Instagram!


Added to your wishlist

Skip to toolbar